Thanks to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) governorâs intervention last year, the Indian banking systemâs woes are, finally, understood well. At the end of FY16, ~17% of public sector banks' (PSBs) assets are stressed. Again, if we optimistically assume that only a third of these assets will be written off, that would imply that ~50% of the shareholdersâ equity of PSBs will be written off by the end of FY18. Based on FY16-end numbers (i.e. without assuming any incremental equity requirement for PSBs to fund future loan book growth), that would imply that the PSBs need $30 billion (equivalent to nearly 1.5% of our GDP) equity infusion over FY17 and FY18. Such a figure compares to the $4 billion budgeted by finance minister Arun Jaitley for infusion into PSBs in FY17 and the $7 billion promised by the finance ministry for PSBs over FY17-19. In short, it is highly unlikely that the government will be able to find the resources required to recapitalise the ailing PSBs.
Capital aside, the PSBs â with a few notable exceptions such as State Bank of India, Bank of Baroda and Union Bank of India â also have major deficits with regards to their IT systems and with regard to their access to managerial talent. Even if the capital was forthcoming, the technology and the talent would still be unresolved issues hampering the PSBsâ road to a highly unlikely recovery.
So, why does this matter? In a country full of deficits, why are we bothered about yet another deficit? Until a decade ago, the PSBs used to account for nearly 90% of loans outstanding in India. After steadily losing market share to the private sector, the PSBs now account for 70% of loans disbursed. Hence, even if we assume that only the bottom half of the PSBs (âbottomâ from an asset quality perspective) run aground, that still accounts for nearly 40% of loans outstanding in the country. As we wheel these bottom-half PSBs into the intensive care unit, we still donât know who or which institution will replace these PSBs in the humdrum but important job of disbursing credit to millions of Indian citizens and hundreds of thousands of small and medium enterprises (SMEs).
There is a ray of hope that in the aftermath of the PSBsâ evisceration we will create a more efficient and effective banking system
Until a year ago, as the credit quality crisis in India gathered steam, we were staring into an abyss. Now, however, the tantalising combination of three different initiatives taken by different arms of the Indian government over the past four years have made it possible for us to envisage a way forward in the post-PSB world:
- The rollout of Aadhaar since 2010 has meant that now nearly a billion Indians have unique identification numbers along with biometric identity proof.
The combination of these three initiatives creates new possibilities for financial institutions, both on the asset side and on the liability side:
- Big data based lending: Rapid technological advances made in analytics are changing the way lending is being done. In China, Alibabaâs financial arm, Ant Financial, in a short duration has scaled up a range of financial products varying from online payments to lending to credit scoring. Carved out in 2011, Ant Financial and its flagship product, Alipay, command more than 82% share in Chinaâs online payment market. This, combined with other services such as wealth management, provides Ant Financial access to rich data (shopping history, utility bills, work and home addresses, property, family links, etc.). Analytics on this data has enabled Antâs lending business to cater to small businesses which were previously neglected by the banks due to sub-par credit scores. Among the online marketplaces in India, Flipkart, Snapdeal and Amazon have begun offering working capital loans to their merchants using merchantsâ selling patterns, ratings, customer feedback and social media profile for credit scoring.
Clearly, there are several major unanswered questions regarding the transition from the current morass to the brave new world of technology-driven banking. Most notably:
- We havenât yet seen any one bank in India nail down the technology on both the asset and the liability side. In part, this is a function of regulation because the payment banks have been focused by the RBI on the liability side whereas the small finance banks â with their microfinance origins â have a greater asset-side orientation.
For the first time, there is a ray of hope that in the aftermath of the PSBsâ evisceration we will create a more efficient and more effective banking system with a new generation of banks in India. It is important that in our haste to clean up the current mess we do not suffocate our nascent alternative banking construct.
Saurabh Mukherjea is CEO (Institutional Equities), Ambit Capital. Penguin will shortly be publishing his next book, âThe Unusual Billionairesâ.
Like this Insight? Sign up for our daily newsletter to get our best reports.