Evaluating risk and reward: A comparative analysis of fixed deposits against other investment instruments

By Team Insights Focus

  • 10 May 2024

In personal financial planning, one of the most important considerations for investors is making the right balance between risk and reward. Among various investment options in India, fixed deposits (FDs) have long been a preferred choice due to their perceived stability and assured returns. However, of late, the emergence of a gamut of alternative investment instruments has challenged the traditional dominance of FDs. This article aims to provide a comprehensive comparative analysis of FDs against other investment avenues, explaining their unique features, risks, and potential rewards.

What makes FDs unique from other investments?

Fixed deposits stand out in the investment world primarily due to their inherent stability and predictability. They offer a guaranteed rate of interest over a specified tenure, providing you with a secure avenue to park your funds. 

Furthermore, FDs are backed by government regulations and are often considered less volatile compared to other investment instruments such as stocks or mutual funds. Choosing a high interest FD such as the IDFC FIRST Bank fixed deposit can offer you better returns over the period and sometimes outperform other market linked investment instruments. With flexible tenures ranging from 7 days to 10 years, and customisable interest payouts (monthly and quarterly), IDFC FIRST Bank fixed deposits can suit all your short- and long-term goals. 

A comparative analysis of fixed deposits and other investments

Fixed deposits and savings accounts

While both FDs and savings accounts offer a secure repository for funds, FDs typically provide higher interest rates than savings accounts. Additionally, FDs impose a lock-in period during which the deposited amount cannot be withdrawn without incurring penalties, whereas savings accounts offer instant liquidity. However, with the overdraft facility such as the one offered by select IDFC FIRST Bank FDs, you can access funds anytime to meet your urgent needs without disturbing your deposits and continue to earn better interest. If you prefer to open a fixed deposit but without having to link it to a savings account, you can now do so with IDFC FIRST Bank’s ‘digital FD’. You can open this fixed deposit in just a matter of minutes with an efficient Aadhaar OTP-based process online without the need of an existing IDFC FIRST Bank savings account. 

Fixed deposits and mutual funds 

Mutual funds, being market-linked instruments, carry higher risk compared to FDs. However, they also offer the potential for higher returns. While FDs assure fixed returns irrespective of market fluctuations, mutual funds' performance is subject to market conditions and the fund manager's expertise. Opting for a high interest rate fixed deposit from IDFC FIRST Bank, you can get guaranteed returns without worrying about the market performance. It is especially suitable for individuals looking to invest in long term growth instruments such as retirement planning or purchasing a house.  

Fixed deposits and stocks

Stocks represent ownership in a company and are riskier compared to FDs. While stocks offer the potential for substantial returns, they are subject to market volatility and company performance. FDs, on the other hand, provide a fixed rate of interest and are not influenced by market fluctuations. Compounding power of a fixed deposit can help you generate higher returns over longer durations risk free. For instance, the quarterly compounding interest rate in IDFC FIRST Bank allows you to earn interest on the principal and previous interest, thus amplifying your returns over longer tenures. 

Fixed deposits and public provident funds (PPFs)

Public Provident Fund (PPF) is a long-term savings scheme backed by the Government of India. PPF offers tax benefits along with a fixed interest rate, making it a popular choice for risk-averse investors. While PPF and FDs share the characteristic of assured returns, PPF has a longer lock-in period and offers tax benefits. While PPF does not offer liquidity, an IDFC FIRST Bank FD provides better liquidity with customisable investment tenures and overdraft facilities. Senior citizens can enjoy premature withdrawals without paying any penalties and can access their hard-earned money anytime.   

Fixed deposits and ULIPs

Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs) combine investment and insurance features, offering investors the opportunity to participate in the market while securing life coverage. ULIPs typically offer higher returns compared to FDs but involve market risk and charges for insurance coverage. If life coverage is not your priority, a fixed deposit with higher returns can be a suitable choice as it offers guaranteed returns without any influence of the market performance.  

Conclusion

The choice between fixed deposits and other investment vehicles comes down to individual risk tolerance, investment goals, and time horizon. While FDs offer stability and assured returns, alternative avenues such as mutual funds, stocks, ULIPs, and PPFs provide varying degrees of risk and potential for higher returns. As an investor, you must carefully evaluate your financial objectives and risk appetite before selecting the most suitable investment option. Diversification across multiple asset classes, including a high yield FD such as the IDFC FIRST Bank Fixed Deposit, can help mitigate risk and optimise returns in the long run.